Walking distance-ish from where we were staying. Fish was so so. Service was excellent but food was bland and dry. Place is really a bar so it was about as clean as you would expect a bar to be. Will not return.
1 - 10 of 153 reviews
I'm not sure why the place closed are you still enjoyed there and went there often,it was a nice place for a cocktail and appetizers I also went there a couple times for dinner and the food was really very good
A location with a terrible history buries another restaurant. Seemed like this one had some potential, but it appears internal and management conflict led to failure. Might be a greedy and short sighted property owner - not an uncommon problem. We wait now, to see...More
Our meal was good, as well as the service, but the Starvin Marlin was nothing special. The rustic décor was a little dreary, but fine. No complaints, but a little pricey for a burger and ribs.
This has been a favorite local restaurant for my wife and me during the year and a half that we've had a house in Brewster. Not fancy or high-end, but reliably good on all counts (except maybe the decor, which was a bit kitschy or...More
Stopped in for dinner with my wife and my daughter who has been sick. She needed to sit outside so the hostess directed us to the rear patio which has many tables with umbrellas. The beer was very cold and the cocktails generous. We started...More
good food served by a polite and caring staff in a comfortable setting. We found it to be a nice quick dinner stop that didn't breaK THE BANK.
Wish I read these reviews before I wasted 100$. Bathroom dirty toilet plugged garbage overflowing floors sticky sink scrimey just gross. Food terrible medium rare steak was a hockey puck and pre sliced? What happened to the menu? This was once a very nice place...More
TERRIBLE!!! Our daughter (8 years old) accidentally left her purse. When she went to get it a few days later and couldn't find it, we backtracked and realized she left it at the Starvin' Marlin. We spoke with the manager who (unapologetically) admitted the cash...More