Awsome icecream in a variety of flavours. Loooovw it! Wish I had room for more. The mudpie was great.
1 - 10 of 124 reviews
This is a recurring visit for many families when on the Vineyard. A great array of flavors to satisfy all.
This was our second time to Mad Martha’s in Edgartown. I just find the ice cream to be very average and the choices to be small. That said, it is an ice cream shop - maybe the sundaes are better.
Ice cream selection small but good. I had a chocolate which was good. Small is still a pretty good size portion. Expensive compared to home- about $5.50 for small cup. Cash only
This ice Cream was tasteless. I had chocolate chip and if I did not get a chocolate chip it just tasted cold. Absolutely no flavor. Very limited choice of flavors and no imagination of flavors. A tourist rip off. Never again
We had gone to the MMs in Vineyard Haven a few times so on our last evening we saved dessert for MM in Oak Bluffs. We walked to the shop to find them mopping the floor and rocking out while cleaning. They must have seen...More
Ice cream was good. Very fresh with a homemade taste. Flavors were interesting. We enjoyed the butter crunch the most. The cookies and cream was disappointing (not the typical version most are used to).
By the end of my trip on the Cape, I really got tired of the cash only business. It's annoying. You have to keep wads of cash because you cannot use 21st century payment systems to buy ice cream. The employees didn't make the experience...More
As someone else said plan to pay $5 for one scoop but less than $6 for 3 scoops? And it's CASH ONLY!! I did not see this sign until we got up to the register.. all this being said it was a cute place with...More