From New Haven CT - so we are picky. The pizza was not great. We had mozzarella and one with fresh tomato. Crust was not tasty. Large pizzas are very small. Would not go back.
1 - 10 of 265 reviews
After eating at 4 other mid-range restaurants in Cape May (our first visit) and not being impressed with any of the meals that we had, we found Mario's Pizza and Italian Eatery. We read the reviews and saw how packed the place was each time...More
Stopped in and got a few slices on my lunch break from work. The staff is so friendly and you are welcomed with a smile! The service was fast and the pizza was really good! I would recommend this place to anyone!
Mario's always delivers so to speak! Actually if you want to eat in this is the place to call for they deliver all over Cape May. Ranging from pizza to burgers platters and hot and cold hoagie's. Quality of food and price is great!
Had an excellent eggplant parm sandwich. Cooked fresh and just right, like Mama used to make! Pizza was good too, but if you are an eggplant parm fan this is THE place! Service could be better, but the food makes up for it!
Stopped in to pick up a pizza order. Met the owner, very hard working friendly nice guy. Even though they were getting orders left and right, he stopped to greet and socialize with every customer. The food was amazing! I will return on my next...More