We got there on a Sunday just as they opened. JoJo the owner was standing out front to greet us. After talking for several minutes he looks at my wife and say Chardonnay (which she always drinks) then looks at me and asks what kind...More
1 - 10 of 265 reviews
It's one of the first or the first restaurant to your left when you get off the bridge that connects city island tot he rest of the world. No long lines trying to get to the middle of the island to the other restaurants.. And...More
My husband and I dined at the City Island Lobster House with another couple. We usually go to Sammy's, but decided to try someplace new, and I was glad we did. The food was so good, and the lobster feast on the menu is a...More
On left after the bridge. The closest place on the island. Valet parking. We were seated immediately. Quick service. Lots of extras (salad, antipasti, apps, garlic bread), all yummy. Food was delicious as were the cocktails.
It started off great: a big portion of delicious garlic bread, cheeses, olives and salad as soon as we sat down. Unfortunately when the mains came, there were very plain ( I would compare to the food from Applebee's). We sat inside where it was...More
I have been to this place at least 5 times. I do not eat seafood but people brag about there "land" dishes and I have yet to find a dish worth bragging about. Each time I have eaten here I had a different meal and...More