I have been here bunerous times since I was a kid. It hasn't changed much. The food is the same and at times bland. It's a crap shoot. Sometimes the food is great other times I barely touch it. This time around was the latter....More
1 - 10 of 302 reviews
Family had an excellent meal on a Friday night. Crowded but seating was available after a 10 minute wait. Several Sammy's on City island. Very nice experience.
I had lunch with friends last Friday there. In the past I had lobster there and it was satisfying. This time I ordered grilled red snapper - it came whole with head on (even though the menu did not indicate it but said so for...More
Amazing portions: First a relish tray with olives, celery and carrots along with a loaf of fresh sourdough bread along with a nice piece of tender cornbread and a piece of cheese. Then comes a very generously sized main course, in our case tilapia for...More
I really like the food at Sammy's Fishbox, but their prices are high. I suppose it's worth it when they run a lobster special, because their Maine lobster is outstanding!
Sammy's is an iconic City Island seafood restaurant. The island is small, but there are lots of restaurants and even a small museum on the main (and only) street that goes end-to-end on the island. The portions are generous and the food is good. It...More
Eight hungry people on a Sunday headed to City Island to a seafood binge. Sammy's is at the end of the long street so don't worry - you didn't miss it, just keep driving. Besides, the signs are large and huge and colourful especially in...More