Everyone seems to like this place, and the service is fine; but the food is totally average, so we can't figure out the fuss.
1 - 10 of 149 reviews
Rosie’s is amazing every time we go with a group the food is as good as it gets. Every dish is prepared perfectly the chicken the fish the macaroni the salads it’s great Italian food with great sauces which makes the difference. The drinks from...More
Dinner was delicious but very noisy, some tables are way to close to each other...great way to make new friends if you are a social butterfly!!! Very good service
We travel in Italy every year so know our Italian food, and Rosies remains one of our two top favorites of all the umpteen Italian/Italian-American restaurants we’ve eaten in, in NYC and the suburbs. Yes, the food is consistently outstanding, but it’s the warmth of...More
It was a Saturday evening and we were a group of five adults, one of whom had been to Rosie's before and who had made reservations for 6:45 pm. (7 pm was not available.) Two of us arrived at 6:40 and were seated immediately. The...More
Great rack of lamb here. The staff are pretty accomodating for young families and are all good natured and friendly. Food is reliably good, drinks are mediocre, parking is scarce, atmosphere is a bit old fashioned but nice enough.
Consistently good food. Can be pretty noisy but never disappoints. Tuna civeche, San Pietro Oreganata (white fish), Spaghetti Umberto are some of our favorites. Great bread too!
casual elegance with excellent southern Italian and Sicilian cuisine Reservation recommended on weekend
Everything, All American dishes.We have dined on many occasions here and never disappointed. It can be harried on a weekend night and reservations are more difficult. Definitely not a drop in restaurant. Their bread is absolutely delicious, but do not stuff yourself as the portions...More
Excellent food. Good service. slightly loud for an upscale restaurant, but definitely won't deter from going back. Definitely make a reservation. Don't expect to walk in and get a table. Will go back.