I love all pizza so I went with my wife's opinion to justify the 5-star rating. We agreed it was the best crust we have ever eaten. The rest of the pizza was very good. They even provided banana peppers even though it was not...More
1 - 10 of 338 reviews
Service was slow but the pizza was decent. The place is pretty filthy inside and out though. I wouldn't eat there again for that reason. Two of the kitchen staff went out to the outside seating area, which was empty at the time, lit up...More
I've had better pizza in my life, but never more generous slices in this. The restaurant is basic but good at what it does. We also appreciated being served even though the place had closed a few minutes before we got there. Recommended.
There are a lot pizza shops in Cooperstown and this one is authentic. The service, food, and atmosphere are truly worth a visit.
It started to rain and so we ducked in here to have dinner. Split a pizza and it was pretty damn good.The slices were gigantic and we only got the medium. I'd hate to see what the large looks like because we barely made it...More