Came here for my anniversary and can't say enough. I have been coming here for years stopped because I moved away. Decided to make the trek and was worth it. Service started off very slow but as we got to know our server it got...More
1 - 10 of 136 reviews
The service was excellent and setting fine. The steak we shared was only ok, but creamed spinach and cocktails and wine were all good as was the bread. However, we did think the total price was high for a steak we didn't find outstanding as...More
I really enjoyed Rothmanns. Its a decent crowd and good service and the food is consistently good. We keep this restaurant in our rotation for date night and haven't been disappointed yet. I wish it was easier to get a drink at the bar when...More
Extremely loud, over-booked, packed! You cannot walk through the dinning room! Average quality, average selection of old time brunch offerings. There is no creativity neither chef's innovation! Several local supermarkets have far better choices. BUT Very gracious staff.
This was by far one of the worst experience I have had at a restaurant. For the amount of money these guys charge the service and the food should be great. But unfortunately, it is below average restaurant. The servers didn't seem interested in taking...More
I have been to Rothmans many times, and I really must say I am never disappointed! My favorite is the Prime Rib, consistently cooked to perfection! The staff is kind and professional. You get what you pay for, and it's truly the best steakhouse on...More
Rothmans is one of Long Island's finest steak houses and serves exceptional steaks cooked to perfection. Never had a bad meal here and been here several times. Definitely a fine dining experience, this place is perfect for special occasions, a romantic dinner, a business meeting,...More
Nice place, good service. Very pricey, even without drinks. The veal porterhouse was great, as were the steaks. The mini-desserts are a good choice after a big meal.