I heard a new manager took over and we decided to give it a try. Had a 4th of July lunch. Everything was excellent from service to quality of food. We will be visiting again.
1 - 10 of 75 reviews
I grew up in Freeport but I've rarely been there, until recently. They have outdoor dining in season with a nice view of the fishing boats coming and going. On Sundays there is a great band if you care to dance or just tap your...More
I've been coming to this place for years and it's a great location, nice views, great live music and ok food. This summer, prices went up considerably without any major upgrades and it seems to be that beers glasses got smaller and prices got higher....More
We attended a private party at venerable Otto's Sea Grill (est'd 1929) in Freeport, NY on Sunday afternoon, May 21. It was our first visit to the historic "nautical mile" on Long Island's south shore, but it won't be our last. A separate room that...More
Do yourself a favor and go somewhere else! Besides the fact that she tells her staff to lie about where her fish comes from,you wont get good service or food worth your money. The cooks in the kitchen are NOT cooks,but shes stuck with them...More
Yes another Hit !! This restaurant will satisfy you. The food is so fresh and promptly made delicious. They are accommodating and informative. All staff is very knowledgeable.
I've been going to Otto's for years, but hadn't been there for a while. This past year I've been there three times, once during the day and twice at night. I've always enjoyed sitting outside at Otto's, having a bite to eat and enjoyed the...More
I have visited Otto's on many occasions throughout the years. It was at one point my favorite restaurant on the Freeport row. The food is now substandard yet the prices have risen. The servers are uncaring and sloppy. Half the time a busboy brings your...More
Waited over 15 minutes once seated till waitress came over. It wasn't even crowded. Several empty tables. Ordered shrimp scampi which was bland and had a reddish sauce on shrimp...chicken Frances also lacked flavor. Penne ala vodka w shrimp was ok but cost $8.00 for...More