Just a small Pizza Business on Old Elmira Road and Great Value for local Pizza.. Having Made a few thousand Pizza's in Ithaca , I have to say Pudgies is one of my Favorites.

The Pizza is really Good if you like the Sauce a Little more Sweeter. i Deeply enjoyed my pizza. And those Wings were so Awesome and Delicious. I would definitely buy from there again. But the down side is there is not much Seating so...More

Recently tried to relive my glorious college days to a visit at Ithaca. I remember eating at Pudgies while in college and thinking is was lousy pizza - going back years later, it was actually not bad, the sauce was tasty and the crust was...More

Cornell's Art Department loves to get pizza from here because it's cheap. Unfortunately eating it can be a traumatizing experience. Please do not get pizza here.

The grandkids love this place.