I've had both pies and slices from this Pizzeria. The pies are hot and delicious. The slices are average at best, reheated and old.
1 - 10 of 28 reviews
When we lived in Larchmont, Nicky's was our spot. Now when we visit family 2-3 times a year ( driving down from Buffalo) we always take back 2-3 pies with us after freezing them. Really no need to freeze, as we usually finish at least...More
The original . The institution . Great Pizza and warm atmosphere . Gino knows everybody in town . Pizza is great .
Love, love, love me some Nicky's Pizza!!! I can't say enough about this place. I always have the regular cheese and tomato pizza and could eat a whole pie were it not for me watching my waistline.
Great pizza from regular to a wide assortment of toppings. Other traditional Italian dishes - all prepared well and good portions. Great for Italian Ice in the summer.
Great pizza always. Ate every Friday Night for years! Nice guys making great pizza and sandwiches as long as I could remember.
Nicky's is our local good Pizza place. They have great pizza of different variety by the slice or pie. There are a few tables out doors as well. I have never had anything else other than pizza here.