We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Lenny's Gift Shop - CLOSED

474 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954-5126
+1 631-668-2500
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent14%
  • Very good21%
  • Average0%
  • Poor0%
  • Terrible65%
15 Jul 2012
“unfortunately it is gone”
6 Oct 2011
“Truly Disgusting”
Restaurant Hours Closed
Seafood, Soups
474 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954-5126
All Details
Reviews (14)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 14 reviews

Reviewed 16 July 2012

Lenny's captured the spirit of Montauk and sadly has been replaced by a trendy place named swallow. The ambience has changed to more of a NYC trendy bistro with small portions and high prices. Didn't feel like we were in Montauk at all.

Thank BishopRaimondi
Reviewed 6 October 2011

Worst meals of our entire lives. When we were seated the first clue should have been the way the "gentleman" threw our menus at us like he was playing cards. All of the food was either too salty or had no taste at all. The...More

1  Thank Cathy S
Reviewed 1 October 2011

Went there for dinner after reading their write up in that free newspaper Montauk Life. Disgusting! I had broiled flounder almondine that tasted like it was frozen AND had absolutly NO FLAVOR AND BURNT SLICED ALMONDS ON IT! My boyfriend had the seafood platter that...More

Thank paulette r
Reviewed 21 September 2011

We went here for lunch Monday, Sept 19th. We were quite disappointed with the food, the New England clam chowder at $6.95 tasted like they just opened a can. The yellow fin tuna sandwich $19.95.was ok but not great! horseradish was really tasteless. The waiter...More

Thank professor_eNewYork
Reviewed 21 June 2011

Let's just say that my meal at Lenny's is in the running for the worst restaurant meal I have ever had. I went here for lunch with a group of 10 people and we had high expectations given the seating on the dock with a...More

Thank giantsteve
Reviewed 15 June 2011

I am a transplanted New Yorker. My family and I return to Montauk every year. We go back to Lenny's several times during each stay. We love the place! The food is good, and the people are great. My daughters love having fun with them....More

Thank nichols1
Reviewed 25 August 2009

This restaurant is worse than the reviews. The food was horrible; the frozen type as mentioned earlier. The place is also extremely dirty. We went on a recommendation and didn't double check Tripadvisor - big mistake. Wish we had walked out immediately. Yes, Mikey is...More

Thank Sedor
Reviewed 22 June 2009

We were both hungry and saw this restaurant by the sea. It appeared to be one of those "fresh off the boat". Poppers for appitizers: the cheeze was cold. Scallop Dinner was about 1/2 cup of BAY scallops, sodas came in "shot glasses". No whole...More

Thank Wefferman
Reviewed 27 August 2008

My family and had a few restaurants picked out. Lenny's was the furtherest from our hotel. We did not want to loose our spot at our hotel. We went and were gonna try this seafood place by the chamber of commerce. We went in this...More

Thank aimster16348
Reviewed 18 August 2008

The food was BAD, after complaing about it, Mikey told us we were treated like Kings!!, Mussels Fra Diablo - bland and tasteless. When i complained that my dish normally has garlic in it, Mikey told me there is more garlic in the Scallops than...More

1  Thank Andy157
Nearby HotelsSee all 39 hotels in Montauk
Haven Montauk
67 reviews
.28 km away
Montauk Soundview Resort Hotel
50 reviews
.36 km away
Culloden House Motel
38 reviews
.37 km away
Sail Inn of Montauk
45 reviews
.38 km away
Nearby Restaurants
Inlet Seafood Restaurant
472 reviews
.39 km away
Gosman's Restaurant
455 reviews
.21 km away
The Dock
202 reviews
.10 km away
Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock
208 reviews
.02 km away
Nearby Attractions
Star Island Yacht Club and Marina
9 reviews
.40 km away
Sailing Montauk's Catamaran Mon Tiki
96 reviews
.71 km away
Mtk Cruises
72 reviews
.44 km away
Viking Fleet
259 reviews
.09 km away
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 474 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954-5126
  • Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Long Island  >  Hamptons  >  Montauk
  • Phone Number: +1 631-668-2500
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing