The winners circle buffet is no longer there its a restaurant. The food is better and they now have a bar.
1 - 10 of 27 reviews
Its a nice little gem in the heart of Sullivan County. The Buffet is delish. And so many choices. Soups, salads, hot or cold foods. All very well prepared. Gaming right outside the Buffet. Something nice to do.
Nice place for lunch while playing the machines at the Casino. Very nice Restaurant, good service and very good food.
They have closed the Winners Circle, no more Buffet! However they have the Terrace , which has been renovated... Menu has been changed, we had the Filet Mignon, and it was surprisingly delicious! Tender steak, fresh broccoli, potatoes, salad was a bit dry, but it...More
The buffet is closed for good due to re-modeling of the casino. There is a pricey restaurant in the casino if you don't mind spending $15 for a burger.
Actually not bad but your basic Casino mediocracy food. But it's exactly what you expect. There's no live dealers everything is machines send it's just OK. It serves its purpose.
NY's Aqueduct and Yonkers casinos no longer have buffets, likely because they do not need to attract more customers to their crowded venues. So this is another reason to love little Monticello.
Our lunch buffet was good, were there on a Tuesday and got a senior discount. Waiter was very nice. Good variety of items to choose from. Wonderful dessert selection.
I got a free ticket to the buffet at the Monticello Casino. The first thing I noticed is that it was nothing like the buffets in AC. They did have shrimp- which was peel it yourself- and it was plentiful. There were about 5 entrees...More
Casino's are famous for their buffet food, Monticello Casino Raceway is the exception. the food is OK but nothing to write home about. Pricey , limited choices, salad bar is the best part of the spread. Tight seating, waitstaff friendly, place quite clean, shrimp fresh...More