Best new York style pizza I have found in a while. My padre and I stop in every time we are in Oneonta and def recommend.
1 - 10 of 64 reviews
Actually got flyer while staying at the Hampton and saw another family eating it there. Looked good and they said it tasted good so we went and checked it out for dinner. Is open late. Can buy pizza by the slice if you chose. Got...More
My family is staying in town for a baseball tourney (Cooperstown). We read about Sals online and decided to check it out. We ordered a large pizza half barbecue half pepperoni it was awesome. I highly suggest you order the "garlic knots" the are .25...More
I grew up in Oneonta, and given the large Italian population in the area, there were many, many great pizza places. There aren't as many now, and a few new ones have sprung up over the years, but IMHO Sal's will always be the best....More
Always a must stop late at night for the cold cheese pizza, it's a must try if you are not from the area, especially late at night. Sal is always there and very friendly to chat with.
I love New York style pizza and Sal's hit a home run with me! We stopped in for a quick slice and were not disappointed. I also had the minestrone soup which was OUTSTANDING! Home-made goodness that I had not obtained at a restaurant (let...More
When our family comes to town, Sal's is one of the places we must eat! They offer many different topping on slices, which are always ready. They also have hot subs and dinners. Always a great value and delicious food!
Sal's is Classic Oneonta. Delicious, sweet, spicy, savory--and a dozen other adjectives-- food. Our families have been going there since the 70's and even now part of the reason we head to Oneonta on occasion is for the chance to score a perfect slice and...More