This diner is great! Staff is very friendly and attentive. Like all diners, there are so many dishes to choose from. I always go with the turkey BLT wrap. So good! It’s great to either have a sit down here or take out. They also...More
1 - 10 of 52 reviews
Service was non-existent...we walked in they sat us and no one came to our table not even to offer drinks...felt like 15 minutes then a group of ladies walked in they sat them and proceeded to take their order while we just sat there...I got...More
Living in Babylon we have many great diners in the area. Atlantis however seems to be our "go to" when my family and I are in the mood for diner food. I also do a lot of my business meetings here at night as well....More
Great place for dinner staff very good and food is wonderful. Cooked to perfection. atmosphere too very comfortable especially when it is hot outside....
Been here every time we come into town. Always get good food and service. Portions are good and so is the quality. They also are very good at receiving a large party.
Like a blast from the past when it comes to talking about the Diner experience with any New Yorker, the Atlantis Diner is everything you should expect to receive: attentive staff, delicious food with enough to take home in a doggie bag, amazing desserts and...More
We enjoyed the meals we ordered but the service was so-so. Came over to check on us only when we had finished eating. Water (our beverage of choice) wasn't refilled in a timely fashion. Might or might not choose this location again. Lots of options...More
Completely rebuilt. Beautiful clean and large! Nice tile work, spacious, TV's at counter. And this place packs them in! The perfect all around diner on Long Island! Ample parking! And not only can you get great food that s fresh for a nice bite... but...More
Had lunch here recently with some friends. Ordered one of my favorite choices - grilled cheese. Nothing fancy, just American cheese on rye, usually a simple and delicious, foolproof choice. It was almost the worst I have ever had. First of all, it was tiny,...More