Peanut Butter pie is the best. In the summer order ahead on Saturday's because they sell out. Friendly staff.
1 - 10 of 131 reviews
Love these Pies.....Always Fresh and Yummy You can order ahead of time (especially if you want more than 1 pie for the Holidays or a Celebration) Or just stop in and see what they have available.....it's ALL Good!!!!!
great pies will reorder fresh large with good amount of filling no like meeders crap will repurchase as needed
If you are in the Westfield, NY, area be sure to stop at Portage Pie to purchase one of their delicious pies. Better yet, check out the menu on their Facebook page and call ahead to order the exact kind that you want. It's hard...More
Seriously. Perfect flaky crusts. Perfect balance of sweet and tart. And when you walk in it just smells. so. good. Get the strawberry rhubarb. If they are out of it, get whatever they have. You will return!
Okay, I don't like pie. If a dessert doesn't have chocolate, I don't even bother. Was going to have one bite of the slice of strawberry rhubarb pie my husband ordered and I ended up eating most of it. Then the next day I made...More