We discovered this place a couple years ago referred by a friend. We really enjoy the food here. Small but family friendly atmosphere. Good portion and prices too.
1 - 10 of 31 reviews
Very thick crust pizza - almost like pizza on a soft pretzel. Probably good enough to compete as one of the best in larger metro markets like Columbus and Cleveland. Nice, quaint little bar in residential area of Conneaut. Service is good. Atmosphere is good....More
I have eaten several times at Pizzi's Café in Conneaut while visiting Conneaut during summer vacations. The food is awesome. We have had their sandwiches, antipasta appetizer, salad and spaghetti with meatballs. We have enjoyed other menu items too. All served hot and all were...More
I used to regularly patronize this business because I love their pizza. But the price point is waaaaaay too high (around $30 for a large with a couple of premium toppings) and the service is poor. Called ahead because it takes an hour, on average,...More
Picked up a pizza. I think it was $12. Had almost no cheese and was way overcooked. I swear it tasted like a Chuck E Cheese pizza. It was that bad! And it was smaller than a dinner plate to boot. Shame on you guys.
We used to be regulars here when we lived in Conneaut. We moved away a few years ago. While out driving we stopped in on Friday night. Not crowded, ordered a pizza which took over 45 minutes to get. Pizza was good, but service slow
This was our 3rd visit to Pizzi Cafe, which is a good indication that we have liked it well in the past. It is a bar, which was ok for the other times. This time, however, it was a disappointment. We normally try to eat...More
We stopped here on our way back from a day on the lake in Erie Pennsylvania. My fiance was in the mood for some pizza so she searched Google (She hasn't downloaded the trip advisor app yet lol) for pizza shops in the area and...More
Dear Brandon, Thank you very much for your kind comments and compliments about Pizzi Cafe. As you noted, our peak times can be very challenging for us. Needless to say we make no excuses for being very busy an unable to provide the necessary greeting...More
On a recent visit during a vacation to my hometown, I was not impressed by my dinner here, a spot that used to be pretty good! My disappointment stems from very lax disinterested service. I ordered a large antipasto salad for dinner, but was served...More