There pizza is much better than some of the other places on the island but $24 for a large pepperoni is a bit ridiculous in my opinion.
1 - 10 of 113 reviews
This place is an institution in the area. really good pizza. They have a bunch of different types for every taste. Very friendly and fast. Open Late for those later night munchies too. We sometimes get one to take back home with us, it's so...More
Not sure what it is about this pizza - but it has been an island tradition for my husband and I for years. Delicious with a variety of toppings to choose from and ready to go when we arrive fir pick up!!!
Pizza & Breadsticks were great. We took them to the Break wall and had a picnic. Great Price for Pizza, Bread Sticks & 2 liter pop - Even got plates, Cups & Napkins
Good handmade pizza. It will be worth the wait if you go late at night. This pizza is apart of the Put In Bay, experience.
Walked in here ate 10:30 PM and had a slice of pepperoni that was pre-made and waiting, and $4. It was hot, medium thin crust with real cheese that was just enough to keep going. Very tasty.
If you are from Sandusky, you know the drill.. you grew up of this pizza and you love it. If you are not from Sandusky. You may wonder what the big deal is. Not bad, but oddly sliced and really rather plain. Head down to...More
The pizza was pretty good. However, $23 for a large carry-out pepperoni late at night is total extortion and unreasonable! I see that a large pepperoni normally is $12.75 and specialties are about $18! Come on! Like I said, the pizza was good, but I...More
Hello Fireandice29- Thank you for your feedback of your experience at our establishment. I would like to take a minute to explain our pricing of our 23.00 late night, ready to go pizza. Our large ready to go is 15 inches with one topping, pepperoni....More
My heading speaks for itself. This place is flocked by drunks who haven't eaten all day. If you need something to put in your belly to soak up the alcohol, this may be the place for you.