Friendly staff, great pizza and we really loved the donation creation pizza we ordered. Very good, you won't be sorry!
1 - 10 of 1,643 reviews
We stopped here after reviewing the restaurant's website online -- and we were hungry! The pizza arrived quickly and was delicious. You could truly taste the ingredients which were not covered in too much cheese. Nice atmosphere and quick service are a plus.
The casual setting of Wild Tomato in Sister Bay is just the best! Great place to take the family and with the Sister Bay park and playground directly behind the restaurant, it helps to keep the kids busy while waiting. Our nephew's family had a...More
Original location in Fish Creek still the best. We tried the new Paisano pizza, new to the menu 2 weeks before. Great flavor and so yummy. We also tried their cheese curds and all I can say is wow! A must try in Door County....More
My wife and I ordered pizza and a salad for dinner takeout. We ordered the Cherry Walnut salad. It was like Door County served on a plate. The dried cherries, walnuts, goat cheese and cherry vinaigrette combined to make a perfect salad; tart, sweet, creamy...More
We went to Wild Tomato (Fish Creek) for dinner with our teenage kids. We all loved the pizza & wait staff was attentive & friendly. We had to wait to be seated but it was a short wait - maybe 10 minutes. Casual atmosphere &...More
This location is so popular that you will probably have to wait for a table. Fortunately they have an outside bar with reasonably priced cocktails to help get the fun started. The cherry walnut salad is a beautiful, delicious starter; the petite size is larger...More
we came at the right time, right before it was very busy for supper. everything closes at 6 so if you want to go here, try to come at 5 or before 5 to avoid wait
21 people including 7 kids between 5 and 10. We put them at a separate table which we all feared was going to be a disaster. Hunter handled the whole group - best service I have ever had. He did whole order from memory including...More