Drive by this restaurant at least twice a year and always think I need to try it out. Well, finally we did and what a surprise. It was so good. It was a Friday night and we did have a reservation. They were very busy...More
1 - 10 of 398 reviews
We were very happy to find Garlic Mike's. This is a very traditional red checked table cloth Italian eatery. The menu has the favorites you would expect prepared and served very well. They have a very good wine list for a small Colorado town and...More
I haven't eaten here twice. Food is solid. Growing up in NY I have really high expectations. They do give you a lot of food tho. We have taken home food on both occasions. Maybe a little pricey for Italian food. Wines were good but...More
Thanks for your comments. Our entree prices range fro $14 to $30 (for filet mignon) Perhaps you were looking at our wine features -by the glass, that are priced a bit higher, because we feature higher end wines by Caymus. These same wines sell for...More
Sophia, Marie, and Mike did an outstanding job of ensuring that we had a great dinner experience last evening. We began with a bottle of a very nice pinot noir, which was the perfect accompaniment to our meal. The garlic soup was outstanding. I usually...More
I'm glad you had a great time. I had seen Garlic Soup prepared on the Food Network. I thought, I need to do this!!! So, I put my spin on it. MORE GARLIC, MORE BUTTER. If might make out winter menu! Thanks for your kind...More
We have had the pleasure of dining here numerous times over the past couple of years. My son plays football for Western State, so we come here a lot. Mike and his staff are always welcoming, and the service and food are always the best....More
Thanks so much for the kind review. No, we aren't the place to get in and get out. All of our food is prepared to order. When we set up our reservation book, we generally give each table an hour and a half per seating,...More
Garlic Mike's is not to be missed if you are anywhere near Gunnison or Crested Butte Co. If you like Italian food, I mean really like Italian food this is the place to come. Either Mike or his daughter is usually on the scene to...More
Thank you for the very kind words! We hope to see you again soon!
We heard this was a good restaurant and we were in the mood for Italian food. A big disappointment. First, the hostess had no idea what she was doing, and refused to take our name to put on the list for a table. Finally, we...More
If your waiter came back to the table 2 or 3 times, why didn't you tell him your salmon was over cooked? And while you were at it, ask for pasta. It comes with entrees. Thanks for joining us!
We have been going to Gunnison in late September to fish for years. Avoided Garlic Mike's because we're Gluten Free (actually pretty paleo, but who's counting) and Italian is all about the pasta. Well friends, were we surprised! Went last year and it was amazing....More
You've said some very nice things! Thank you! We aren't just about the pasta. Many GF offerings. See you next year?!
I absolutely love Garlic Mikes. They're one of my favorite restaurants in Gunnison. Great, authentic Italian food and friendly staff. If you haven't tried their corn chowder, I highly recommend it. They have a wonderful wine selection too. Love the new River Bar too! Just...More
Thanks for the kind words! We take pride in our Corn Chowder-although only available in sommer months. Thanks for joining us!
We went on a Monday night and the place was “hopping”!! It is a old building on the outskirts of town , unassuming .... but the atmosphere makes up for the quaint decor. The service was excellent, efficient and friendly. The meal was Italian homefare,...More
We are glad you enjoyed your experience! Please, come join us again!