This place makes the best slice of pizza we have ever had - anywhere in the world (that we have been anyway). It's crisp and tasty and hot. Just heaven in a slice.
1 - 10 of 575 reviews
There's nothing else like it - the toppings, the crust, the base - all amazing. We were here on a Tuesday night and there was no queue and plenty of seats. If it's busy, try again later as it'd definitely worth it.
I tried it twice - may be I missed something at the first time? People are lined for this pizza and whole interior design is promoting the idea that this place has a very good pizza. It is not. There is a place a block...More
This is a long overdue review from last November and this February. This was one of the most highly recommended places for Pizza in NYC and turned out to be first on our itinerary. As I walked it, noticing the intensity of the kitchen staff...More
The Pizza here is the real deal. Crust is right; sauce is exceptional. Toppings are fresh. It's behind MSG and Penn Station. So go when you arrive in NY, and again when you leave.
Authentic NYC Pizza by the slice. Got a few different slices for my wife and three kids. Pepperoni, sausage, supreme, meat lovers, and fresh mozzarella with basil. We liked everything! Huge, thin crust slices that were among the best pizza we've ever had! Will definitely...More
My family visited Pizza Suprema during a short trip through the city. We wanted to try a great NYC slice and walked here in the rain from our hotel. This place did not disappoint. We each ordered two slices of various kinds. All were excellent....More