We were on a family vacation and originally from NY so we love seeking out pizza places. This place was just like home! The pizza was awesome, the garlic knots were great and it has been a long time since I had a pepperoni roll...More
1 - 10 of 24 reviews
This was the highest rated Pizzeria near our campground. Ordered a this crust, well cooked large pizza to go. Picked it up, and asked them to keep it longer, as it wasn't cooked well. When we got it home, it still wasn't well cooked, and...More
I work nearby and this pizza is delicious! Very thin crust. Haven't had anything I didn't love there. The lasagna pizza is my favorite!
First Nickys has great food, the pizza is a good as you will find and the employees are great. So I would recommend them for there food. The single biggest drawback is that they are just super slow and when you dont have much time...More
I used to rate Nicky's at 5 stars. Their calzones were as good as anything you could get in New York. Seems they are now are putting the Georgia spin on calzones. Just horrible. Just cheesy bread at this point. I wish they would learn...More
Went here for lunch with buds. Lunch special is 2 slices and a drink. Slices are large. I had a slice of lasagna and pepperoni. Pizza is pizza but this place is one of the better pizzas I've ever had. Good comfort food and friendly...More
Lot's of menu options...something for everyone. Staff seemed to really take care in the pie's they were making. Left very satisfied.