I enjoyed the key lime pie from Steve’s. I got the traditional. It’s a bit pricey but good. I would have preferred a slightly less crumble to the pie crust.
1 - 10 of 64 reviews
A must visit if you enjoy key lime pie. Steve's offers outdoor seating and is located about 300 feet from a park that overlooks the Statue of Liberty! Friendly cashier made the visit even more enjoyable. I heard you have to try the pies covered...More
My friend and I stopped here and got a small key lime pie to go after visiting Red Hook Winery. There was a line out the door but they move it fast. I am so unbelievably glad we got this. It was super authentic to...More
My wife and I had greatly enjoyed Steve's key lime pies in the past and decided it would be fun to cap our driving lesson this past Sunday with a trip to his store for pies and a walk in the nearby park. As soon...More
Key lime pies here are absolutely delicious. The one with Belgian chocolate is only available from the shop - so be sure to try it. Assuming you don't have a car, you can take the B61 bus and get off at the corner of Van...More
Yes, this is a very true statement! I've tried "other" key lime pies, but I have to say that Steve's pies always rise to the top of the list! Even though I live on the other side of the country, I won't go anywhere else...More