We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Want the lowest hotel prices? You're in the right place. We check 200+ sites for you.

Italian Restaurants in Fire Island

Sort by:
Relevance
Ranking
Name
We found great results, but some are outside Fire Island. Showing results within 40 km of Fire Island.
Limit search to Fire Island.

Michael's Ristorante & Pizzeria (Ocean Beach)

#1 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza Seafood Healthy

Cherry Grove Pizza (Cherry Grove)

#2 of 21 Results
$ Map
Visitor photos (2)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

The Pines Bistro and Martini Bar (Fire Island Pines)

#3 of 21 Results
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Vinnie's Mulberry Street (East Islip 9.6 km away)

#4 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (3)
Menu
Matched on: Pizza Italian

Da Noi Italian Restaurant (Islip 10.3 km away)

#5 of 21 Results
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (4)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Mannino's (Oakdale 10.6 km away)

#6 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (8)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Verace (Islip 10.2 km away)

#7 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (28)
Menu
Matched on: Italian
Reserve

Butera's (Sayville 11.6 km away)

#8 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (5)
Menu
Matched on: Italian
Reserve

La Tavola (Sayville 11.3 km away)

#9 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (10)
Menu
Matched on: Italian
Reserve

Francesco's Trattoria (East Islip 9.6 km away)

#10 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta (East Islip 9.6 km away)

#11 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Vinnies Mulberry Street (East Islip 9.6 km away)

#12 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

A S Italian Fine Foods (East Islip 9.7 km away)

#13 of 21 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Seafood

Original Mama's (Oakdale 10.1 km away)

#14 of 21 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza Seafood

Sal's Pizza (Sayville 11.3 km away)

#15 of 21 Results
$ Map
Visitor photos (8)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Mama's Italian Restaurant (Oakdale 10.7 km away)

#16 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

The Pie at Salvatores (Bay Shore 11.1 km away)

#17 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Frank and Maria's Italian Pork Store (Bay Shore 11.1 km away)

#18 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Ralphs Italian Ices (Bay Shore 11.2 km away)

#19 of 21 Results
$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian

Gio's Pizzeria (East Islip 10.6 km away)

#20 of 21 Results
$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Tina's II Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria (Bay Shore 10.6 km away)

#21 of 21 Results
$$ - $$$ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza