I am having so much trouble deciding on whether to rent a cottage from Pirates Den or the like on AMI or a cottage at the Castaway, Tween the Water Inn or Jensen's on the Sanibel/Captiva Island area. Please help me decide! We plan on parking and not packing up and driving anywhere, staying on the beach with our little boys ages 5 and 7, enjoying beautiful clean beaches and finding cool shells , fishing (renting a pole would be great), local restaurants, a local store, and having a pool would be great as well. We just want to be away from the crowds , the noise and have family fun . How far apart are the two if we want to visit whichever one we do not decide to stay on?