Quick summary: very good, well-prepared food. Friendly, attentive, professional service. Not cheap, but prices in line with the quality.
We stayed 5 nights at the lodge and were generally not in the mood to go too far for dinner. The menu here is broad enough to please most, highlighting the bounty of the area (steaks, bison, chicken, pork, pastas, trout, salmon, etc.) All was very tasty and well-prepared. (I usually remember to keep my receipts on top, but I generally remember that mains were in the high $20's - $30's, and came with appropriate starch and veg.) We usually started by splitting one of the generously-sized salads (the "mural salads" is an nice assortment of greens and veges; the salad with smoked trout was very tasty, around $12, I think.)
The dessert lineup leans to the fancy, more complicated side, and looks good, but has room for improvement. First, there is a nice line-up of after-dinner ports and drinks, and begs for a cheese plate, but no cheese plate or other savory was noted on the dessert menu. The waiter mentioned that we could order the charcuterie plate on the apps menu, but we just wanted cheese after a dinner, and would have been perfect with port. (We had the charcuterie plate in the Blue Heron bar before, and knew it would be too much unless we took some back to the room.) Other nights I would have just liked a dish of huckleberry ice cream, served without the cake or pastry that was listed on the menu. Again, the waiter mentioned that that might be possible, but why not put this simpler option on the menu?
Full bar with wines by the glass or bottle, reasonably priced for a nicer dining environment.
Friendly, professional, attentive service every night. Very well trained and customer oriented.
Gorgeous view of Jackson Lake and the Tetons. Lovely historic murals decorate the room.
If I'm being picky, it would have been nice to have had some more interesting specials. After 4 nights in the Mural room (we had some meals in the Blue Heron and Pioneer Grill for a dinner and lunch,) we were starting to exhaust the menu items we were most interested in. After touring the national parks for a few weeks, I was less interested in a steak or bison burger, and starting to crave something with a spicing from other parts of the world. But again, that's getting picky. The food and preparations were excellent, and they are willing to work with you, e.g. substituing a different starch for polenta, which I'm not fond of. And again, there are a few other places in the area for dinner, but we just wanted to mosey over rather than get in the car again.
So -- if we are ever in this area agani, we'd be delighted to stay and dine at the Jackson Lodge.