It's no secret that getting a breakfast in Long Island is difficult as it's just not that type of vacation island so the next best thing is going to a local bakery - this is where Erica's comes to save your day!
It's cash only but the least expensive place on earth - for 3 pastries; coffee cake, lemon bar and the delicious and absolutely outstanding banana bread we paid $7!!! It's probably the least we ever spent on any "breakfast" while on vacation, and it was delicious!
The place is also a store and you can find many grocery type of items here so super convenient, especially since it's open daily 7AM to 6PM.
TIP: For me the cherry on the top would be a coffee served at Erica's but they are not a restaurant but a bakery and a shop run from an inside of Erica's home from what it looked to us, so don't expect tables or service here, you buy your items and go - we ended up returning to our hotel and enjoy our bakery goods with some tea and coffee made by ourselves :)