Long Island , Clarence town. We bought some very lovely cake with Erica, who is a very nice “Baker”
Next time we will be back for bread

We stayed in the north at CSM this time while visiting Long Island, but decided that before we head up north for the long drive we will stop at Clarence Town area, where we stayed during our original June 2021 visit to this beautiful island, and of course stop at Erica's to pick up some of that amazing Banana Bread!

We added some Marble Cake (they had also Pound Cake, and Raisins Cake) and this ended up our amazing breakfast the next day at CSM :) - the table picture is from that resort, not to confuse with Erica's - which is basically a grocery store (selling some small souvenirs as well) inside Erica's house on top of the hill with a nice view of Clarence Town.

TIP: still cash only, $3.5 per piece, so for $7 we had amazing dessert/breakfast - the pieces are big and very rich! trust me you will love it

Drove to find this place. Easier to find when you are driving back from Gordons since you can see the sign. By the time we got there in the afternoon, there was only a couple of items left but there was some rum cake left and we had that. Probably the best rum cake I have ever tasted and I have had a few rum cakes in my time.
Worth finding the place.

A nice little bakery on island. Did not have a lot of bakery items as we got there a cruise ship had just left the day before. Was able to get 2 little cakes. Okay

If you eat anywhere in the Bahamas this is the place to visit.
Rated by best taste:
1) The Rum Cake is better than anything in a box. Get it warm and it is absolutely amazing. This was the best food I had in Long Island and in Nassau. It made my top 5 deserts in my life!
2) The banana bread is on point. I had to come back the next day to get it.
3) Pound cake is amazing
4) Chocolate pound cake is super tasty

Insanely cheap too, the staff is so friendly and nice! They have homemade Italian ice in the back, in different flavors, just ask for it.