5th St Steak House has been hyped as the best in Chico. I disagree very much.
The ambience was definitely lacking. Overcrowded and very noisy. My husband and I went there for our 32 year anniversary. My husband made the reservation, and before he could request a quite booth,the hostess?ended the call. As a result we were given the booth directly behind the hostesss desk and the front door. Needless to say, we had to almost shout to hear each other over all the commotion.
Your website said Dressy, but you don't hold to that. Levi's, baseball caps, etc. I don't call that Dressy. I suggest you just say "Casual, we don't care, as long as you can spend lots of money!"
Now, to the food. Prawn cocktail 4 stars, 6 oz. Fillet, 4 stars, tender, moist, but a little bit cool. Spinach saute, way too well done, too much balsamic vinegar? Horseradish cream sauce very good. Garlic mashed potatoes tasted like a boxed mix. Rib eye,1 star, 1/3rd of it was fat, and it was very thin. It was very tender, but at that price we expected a better steak. My husband said he's gotten a steak at Denny's just as good and for a lot less.
Very dissatisfied, and would not recommend as the best Steak House.
Way over hyped and over priced.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.