We wandered into NY&C Pizza strolling down Wilshire one day. The logo was kinda cool on the door, and the atmosphere itself was fun inside. It seemed fairly authentic. There was a great server there who chatted with us. We ordered a couple specials. Figured, can't go wrong! But the pizza was downright DISGUSTING. Not just disgusting, inedible. Something a child would make, a small child. It was greasy, runny, the cheese was gooey and dripping everywhere. You literally could not pick it up cause all the toppings fell off when I tried to eat it and the pizza just went limp and soggy. I'm really mad at myself for not insisting that we get our money back. Cause at the end of the day, there's some responsibility on us as customers/diners to voice when things are bad vs just accepting then trashing it later. So, I should have done that. Since I did not, I cannot account for how they would have handled it. I'm really puzzled by the four star reviews for it on Trip Advisor, albeit, only a few total, but wondering, were they just having a really bad day when we came in? Did they change staff? I agree with the reviews about the nice, spacious, replicated NY atmosphere, but I can honestly say that it's probably the worst pizza I've ever had. With the exception of the truck stop in Barstow. Ouch.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.