Had their pizza today instead of pasta and so happy I finally tried it. Had the 'Buenissimo' but substituted the broccoli for pepperoni. Everything about this pizza was superlatiave: the dough, sausage and fresh mushrooms all combined for the best tasting pizza in the entire island.I didn't trust locals who raved about it because many know only US fast food brands and have little exposure to real pizza. Trust me when I say this is the REAL DEAL. I am a local but have tried pizza from Italy to the best on the Americn east coast and Cafe Amici really holds its own
I only wish they would standardize the owner's mother's lasagna recipe. It's rarely the same anymore. The original recipe is outstanding but the chefs need a refresher on how its done. All in all Cafe Amici is a hidden gem.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.