This restaurant has it all. Great location, laid back style, fabulous food, reasonable prices, and friendly service. They serve both Mexican and family style food. The quessdillas and enchiladas are really good here. However, the hidden gem is their lightly battered Cod Fish Fry. The basket comes with a huge side of delicious French fries and five pieces of fish. The batter is light and never greasy. I felt I could indulge both of my cravings on this night, so I ordered a side of their rice as an extra. The rice was perfect with just the right amount of spiciness. Both the Mexican menu and their regular menu has a lot of variety. The menu and the lively atmosphere are worth a trip to Sister Bay. I can recommend Mary and Erin as two of the best waitresses there. And don't forget to order the Fish Fry basket. You won't be disappointed!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.