Be prepared to wait...easily twenty minutes if 1) there's a long enough line and 2) if the people in front of you order bagels like they order coffee at Starbucks.
Be prepared to not regret it. With a wide variety of bagels from which to choose and a million ingredients to fill them, you'll need a statistician to calculate the combinations.
Though the interior is quite small for the large following, just take it to go and enjoy your treasure at your (other) destination. There are stools inside, but this is New York: no one's rushing through their breakfast so you can get nice and comfy. I had the bagel and lox--holey moley, these people know what they're doing! So much flavor! So much food!
The service isn't the speediest, but remember the whole thing about not regretting it?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.